Mod Description:

This modification was designed and completed by Professor Randy T. Agee, D.Ed., April 2009, on a Cedar Creek 34SATS fifth wheel trailer. This article carries a copyright. Permission must be obtained from the author before duplication or reposting. Contact professor95@comcast.net

A fellow campin’ buddy and his wife had joined Nancy and I around the glowing embers of a campfire. We were toasting some marshmallows as I detailed the specifics of the modification described below. When I was finished with my description, I commented that in reality the modification was totally overkill as the same thing could easily be accomplished with a 2 gallon bucket from the Dollar Store.

David’s reply to my statement was novel, “You do it that way because you can”.

Mod Difficulty:

12-volt DC diaphragm pump commonly found in most RVs

On-off switch used to control grey water pump

Fresh water isolation valve - goes between fresh water supply and grey water supply

Holding tank outlet cap with garden hose fitting - supplies pump with grey water

He was right. Many of the modifications I make to our RVs are done simply because I can. And why not? I enjoy dreaming up, designing and implementing these modifications. Of course, I am always careful not to do anything that will compromise safety or the structural integrity of the RV.

One of our favorite camping spots is at Big Meadows on the Skyline Drive in Virginia. The mountains are absolutely magnificent; the deer so tame they walk right up to your campsite and an occasional black bear may ramble down a nearby path. We generally make the trip up to the mountain at least twice a year.

Like many federal campgrounds, Big Meadows does not offer any hookups at the RV site. The campground’s dump station and potable water supply for RVs is almost a mile away. Thus, you must contain and pump your own water and deal with your waste by using the appropriate RV holding tanks.

Our fifth wheel camper has a 62 gallon fresh water tank while the bath, galley and toilet holding tanks are 40 gallons each, for a total of 120 gallons of waste water storage.

Depending on the length of our stay, we often have the need to refill the fresh water tank and remove waste water from the bath tank. The galley and toilet holding tanks are more than adequate in capacity for storing waste water for at least a week. Conservation of both our fresh water and bath tank waste water space is important if we wish to avoid time consuming refills and dumps using portable containers. Of course one way to accomplish this is simply not to shower. But, in our camper that is not going to happen. The wife likes clean bodies on our sheets and I do not like sleeping on the couch.

I got to thinking about this before we made our spring trek to the mountains and came up with an idea that evolved into a RV plumbing modification that I believed would save both fresh water and grey bath holding tank space.

What bothered me was how we used fresh water to flush the toilet. In my way of thinking this was wasteful. Why do we need fresh water when we have a tank full of slightly used bath water? If I could devise a simple method of routing bath tank grey water to the toilet I would not only save fresh water but I would reroute some of the bath tank water to the black tank, which really has excess capacity when dry camping.

The plan involved installing a cut-off valve so that the fresh water supply could be completely isolated from the potty’s water flush line. Water from the bath tank would then be pumped to the potty for flushing. A switch next to the potty would allow us to turn the pump off at night or when we reverted back to a fresh water flush system. This switch could easily be located next to the pump rather than on the wall. I just liked having the switch accessible.

I had an unused Shurflo 12 Volt DC diaphragm pump that I had swapped out for a more efficient microprocessor controlled variable flow pump a few months earlier. I mounted this pump on the utility wall in the basement of the camper (photo #1) and ran wiring for an on/off switch up through the floor of the potty area so it resides next to the potty (photo #2). Similar pumps are available from a number of suppliers. Northern Tool is one source that has pumps in the $50 range. You do not need a high flow pump. One of the smaller 40 psi pumps that provide 1 gallon per minute should work fine.

The next task was to cut into the water line to the potty and insert a cut off valve so that it would be totally isolated from the fresh water system when turned to the off position. On the potty side of the cut-off valve I added a “T” into the line that is connected to the output of the Shurflo pump with a brass 1/2″ NPT pipe fitting to 3/4” garden hose fitting (photo #3). This fitting was found at Lowe’s and includes its own cut off valve so that there is no backflow when I return to using the fresh water system. Since the water lines are PEX, you will need special fittings or the tool for crimping the collars as I described in my Water Accumulator submission. Actually, the accumulator I showed there is now being used in this potty water flush system.

The intake of the Shurflo pump has a male fitting to connect to a 10 foot length of regular garden hose. The other end of the hose is connected to the water hose size adapter on the end of the main dump outlet (photo #4). If your RV has the solid cap it can be easily exchanged for one with the garden hose connection. Most any RV parts and accessory store carries the caps with the garden hose outlet. The bath water tank dump valve is left open so water is present at the outlet.

It worked great! Yes, it may be overkill, but if you enjoy dreaming up and making mods to your RV this one is pretty cool. If you don’t like doing unnecessary mods, get yourself a bucket.

ModMyRV recommends these parts for this mod:
SHURflo 2088-422-444 Classic 2.8 GPM Pump
SHURflo In-Line Filter - 1/2″ Barb Input x 1/2″FPT Output
Valterra Products, Inc. F02-3106BK Black Bulk EZ Coupler Valve Cap with Handle

19 Comments For This Mod

1. Bob Vaughn (July 23rd, 2009 at 6:14 am)

   We used to camp at Big Meadows on the B R parkway every winter…..
   I would be concerned about the soap scum clogging up the diaphragm in the water pump. plus slivers of soap that tend to go down the drain……Otherwise it sounds like a neat way to get rid of bath water……..It may even clean your black water tank in the process….
2. ModMyRV (July 23rd, 2009 at 6:39 pm)

   That could be a problem over time. I would add a pump strainer on the inlet side to protect the pump. This would catch the big pieces but likely would have to be cleaned on occasion.
3. Professor95 (July 25th, 2009 at 5:45 pm)

   I do have a screen strainer on the input to the pump. It is one of those strainers with a rubber washer attached that is used on washing machine lines. If fits inside the female end of the garden hose fitting. I put it there primarily to catch hair that may be in the bath water. Iapologize for neglectecting to include this info when I put the mod article together - I totally forget about that piece. You know what they say about getting old…. Your memory is the second thing to go. I don’t remember what they said the first thing was.

   Soap slivers would not be a problem in our system as we only use liquid body wash soaps.

   - Randy Agee (mod author)
4. ModMyRV (July 25th, 2009 at 6:25 pm)

   Thanks for the clarification professor95. I like washer screen idea better than the pump strainer. It’s both cheaper and easier to get to for cleaning. And good point on the soap slivers. I too use liquid soap. Why? Because I did the shower dispenser mod:

   http://www.modmyrv.com/2009/02/16/rv-shower-soap-shampoo-lotion-dispenser

   Now what was I saying?
5. DumOleBob (August 10th, 2009 at 11:54 am)

   This is about as clever a Mod as I’ve seen! We only boondock and recycling the gray water is a terrific idea. My concern is there is so little space in our 23′ rig I don’t know where the hardware might fit. BUT, I will think on it!.

   Anyway, Mr. Professor - YOU DA MAN!!!
6. wclogger1 (August 20th, 2009 at 5:47 pm)

   Great idea, I have just done mine but used a 3 way Sea Tech valve & one way check valve to prevent backflow. I also installed a 3″ wye between my grey drain valve & my extra termination valve for pump inlet. Otherwise,it’s terrific.
   Rgds, Bob
7. Robert (August 23rd, 2009 at 4:53 pm)

   There is absolutely no way I would ever implement this modification. After using the pump and gray water to flush the toilet, the line is filled with gray water. Then if the valve is switched to use fresh water, it means that the line has gray water with fresh water right behind it. Even with all the backflow prevention valves in the world, I wouldn’t want to take the chance of contaminating my fresh water tank. Gray water contains numerous bacteria that simply do not belong in the fresh water tank. Things like backflow prevention valves do not work perfectly.

   [Offensive content deleted per forum rules by admin on 09-07-09]
8. DP (August 28th, 2009 at 12:15 pm)

   Nice mod Doc.. The water line terminates at the potty either way and has more of a contamination potential in my opinion that the fresh water connected directly to the toilet. whoops, that last sentence came out like most of my projects. Where does this extra “,” go?
9. Professor95 (August 30th, 2009 at 5:56 pm)

   To Robert,

   Sorry, my degree is not in English. Yes, the “I” should have been a “me”. Thanks for the correction.

   Your comments about having fresh water behind gray water when switching back to a normal system are interesting. Apparently you are of the opinion that the contaminated gray water might flow backwards into a pressurized line or perhaps the bacteria will somehow migrate back into your fresh water tank.

   After thinking about your concerns, I will have to agree that there is a remote possibility of cross contamination if the water source was switched and the operator did not make an effort to flush any remaining gray water out of the line to the potty. Allowing a system to rest under this condition would not be a good idea. Simply remembering to properly flush the water lines by running fresh water into the potty should remove any chance of cross contamination.

   wclogger1,
   The inclusion of a check valve into the line before the diverter valve is an excellent idea. I totally agree that this inexpensive device should be part of the modification.

   Professor95
10. Lloyd BC (August 31st, 2009 at 7:21 am)

    This looks like a great idea, but I would delete the fresh water option (our toilets don’t require water to flush), tap into the ‘grey’ line before the valve, with a shut off to enable filter cleaning, thus eliminating all cross-contamination concerns. As I need to replace my ‘grey’ valve, I may just install the pick-up connection now. You can always use a bucket of fresh until you build some ‘grey’ stock. There are ‘Home’ systems being marketed world-wide that do just this. Let’s face it, water shortages world-wide are making us be a little more careful with wastage. A possible added advantage would be the soapy flush water helping to keep the bowl clean.
11. Lloyd BC (September 7th, 2009 at 6:59 pm)

    I’m seriously looking at this as my next mod, But as I said before, I’m going to eliminate the ‘Fresh’ option. We have a ‘79 Layton 22′. I think I have found the perfect spot for the ‘grey’ pump. Below the fridge and furnace where there used to be a useless space, I have installed a Xantrex XD40 3-stage charger/converter. Behind and left of this is an empty space to the rear of the fender well. All of the water supply lines to the bathroom, including a double ‘T’ with lines to the shower, toilet, basin, are at the front of this space, and the grey discharge line is just below and rear. I’m having seepage problems with the existing grey valve, so I’m going to place a new valve between it and the main discharge, and a tap-off fitting between the existing and new valves, to supply the grey pump. All I will have to do is open the old valve while keeping the new one closed (of course the two valves will provide reasonable isolation of grey from black weater). The grey pump control switch will mount just below the fridge, alongside the furnace. As for fittings required to provide the tap-in: (1) 1-1/2″ ABS san.T, (1)1-1/2″ABS X 1/2″ FIPT reducing bushing, (1)PVC 1/2″MIPT x male garden hose adapter (irrigation dept).
    By the way, replacing the old converter with the Xantrex, in its new location, has allowed me to gain a ‘pots and pans’ cupboard below the stove, where the old converter lived (and died).
12. Don (Sneaks) (October 6th, 2009 at 6:53 am)

    I too would be worried about cross contamination and would pass on this mod even with a check valve. But I would consider building a separate grey water transfer system simply because like you, my grey water tank fills long before the black tank. Using fresh water for toilet flush doesn’t really impact the amount of total fresh water carried. I’m for eliminating even the remotest chance of cross contamination. That’s why cities mandate anti-siphon valves in home sprinkler systems, a far cleaner system than our grey water semi cesspool.
13. Professor95 (October 7th, 2009 at 6:20 am)

    Many concerns have been expressed on cross contamination using the gray water flush modification. I cannot unequivocally say that this could not occur. The risks involved are dependent upon potential failure of a valve(s) and, of course, operator error.

    I have re-examined my original install and have added a check valve to the system as a secondary fail-safe device. I am comfortable with the mod on my coach - primarily due to the piping arrangement and the remoteness of the PEX supplying the flush water to the potty.

    The toilet in our RV uses considerably more water than those in previous units we have owned. The previous style foot operated Thetford plastic models could be flushed with little more than a teaspoon of water. Unfortunately, the porcelain Sea Land toilet in our CC does not allow for frugal water conservation. Without changing the valving on the Sea Land, considerable fresh water is used due to the auto bowl refill feature.

    Any modification made to a particular model RV may not be practical or possible on a differing model. Each mod has to be evaluated for the environment in which it will be used. This mod should not be done if you are unsure of or uncomfortable with issues related to cross contamination in your particular application. The old gray water bucket by the potty trick still works well!
14. Lloyd BC (October 16th, 2009 at 8:16 pm)

    Sorry to hear that your ‘Thundermug’ is such a water guzzler, and sure glad that neither myself nor my buddy have that brand. We ‘Boondock’ 99.9% of the time. I don’t often have a water problem (40gal fresh, 30 gal. grey and black), but my buddy, with only 15 gal fresh, has to refill quite often. That’s why both he and I have 12V transfer pumps and carry water jugs.
15. Mark Cowperthwaite (October 18th, 2009 at 2:15 pm)

    We live in our RV full time, a family of 5, soon to be 6. We have a 33′ Nomad Scout. We are currently rigged up(and it seems to be a pattern) that we have water and power available, but no septic dump. We currently haul a tank a week up across the neighbors lawn, about 500′ and you can’t use the ball attachment as the lawn is too unstable. I would be inclined to use this mod, but not bother with the fresh water switch, just use the grey water, thus no backflow issues. Great ideas, I am hungry for more.
16. Mike Miller (November 6th, 2009 at 5:20 pm)

    I too would be concerned with the connection of grey and fresh water systems. (But I like the term: ‘Thundermug’!)

    I you have a low water using version of the ‘Thundermug’, you could run the grey water to a hand sprayer that is next to the ‘Thundermug.’ Just spray down the bowel to flush. The soap in the grey water should help the black tank handle waste.

    Another change to consider would be to tap the side of the grey tank a few inches from the bottom. Solids and the like should stay in the tank. The hair filter is a good idea.

    Mike Miller
    Hillsboro, Or
    1978 GMC Birchaven
    1973 GMC 26 foot.
17. Lloyd BC (November 12th, 2009 at 8:19 pm)

    My feeling is that you want to make the mod as simple as possible, and tapping into the side of the tank adds complexity. Using a short section of garden hose (or an old washing machine water hose) with its screw attachment, along with the washing machine screen, should take care of any hair or solids. Also, if you tap into the side of the grey tank, you have to wait longer to build up sufficient water for flushing.
18. GC (January 27th, 2010 at 2:13 pm)

    I implemented grey water recycling in my coach May 2008 and have enjoyed almost double the days without hookups ever since. I find it better balances my grey and black tanks so they become full at about the same time with fresh water left over (I like to be sure I have some fresh water left as a safety). I used a purchased system from USI-RV which gave me all the parts to tap into the side of my grey tank, filters, tubing, etc. Installation took a little while but it looks very professional and integrated into the coach. The install instructions were very easy and complete.
19. GC (January 27th, 2010 at 2:16 pm)

    Oh, sorry the web site is http://www.usi-rv.com
    GC

Let's hear your comments about this mod!